Propmodo ran a piece Thursday from Bob Mostachetti at Planon with a headline that should sting a little: an office building creates more data than the finance team, so why can't anyone use it? His argument is simple. Real estate is the second-largest operating expense at most companies, behind only payroll, and the data that explains it lives in a building management system, a maintenance platform, or a spreadsheet. Nowhere near the general ledger. Nowhere near the people approving capital.
He's right about the gap. His fix is where I get off the train.
WHAT'S HAPPENING
Mostachetti's answer is to wire building data into the ERP so the CFO can finally see what a building costs. Fine. Do that. But cost data tells you what you spent. It doesn't tell you what anyone valued. And the renewal decision that makes or breaks your NOI gets made on the second question, not the first.
Here's what tenant behavior across our portfolio is saying right now, with the names stripped out.
September is a return to meetings, not a return to the office. With two-thirds of the month on the books, standard conference room bookings are already about a quarter above all of August. Event space bookings have already passed August's full-month total by more than double. Private office bookings, same story, more than double. Meanwhile roof decks, sleep pods, and quiet rooms are flat to down on a per-day basis. Tenants came back in September to be in a room with other people. Leesman's Focus Forward survey of 132 senior CRE leaders found 70% keep the office for collaboration and knowledge exchange. The booking data says the employees agree.
Badge data backs it up. Over the last eight weeks, Tuesday through Thursday account for roughly two-thirds of all successful door unlocks across the portfolio. A Friday runs at about 60% of a Tuesday. Not news to anyone who's walked a lobby lately, but it's the difference between knowing it and being able to price it.
And the divergence is brutal. Spring to summer, same three months, same weather, same interest rates: the top quartile of buildings in our portfolio roughly doubled their bookings. The bottom quartile lost 40% or more. A mixed-use property in lower Manhattan, an office park outside Atlanta, a landmark tower in Chicago all grew through the dead months. Plenty of trophy addresses went the other direction.
Now the confession. Hear me out. The single largest booking category across our entire platform, every month this year, is "Other." Somewhere between a quarter and a third of everything tenants book. That's on us and on our customers. Data you can't label is data you can't act on. Mostachetti's whole point, proven in our own database.
WHY IT MATTERS
The asset manager's real question was never "what does this building cost?" It's "will this tenant renew, and at what number?" A general ledger can't answer that. Booking behavior, badge patterns, and amenity spend can, and they can answer it 12 to 24 months before the broker shows up with a competitive set.
We've quantified the Experience Gap: buildings that can't deliver on experience run 17% lower rents and a 23% drag on NOI. Most of that gap isn't a spend problem. It's a visibility problem. The building knew the tenant was disengaging. Nobody was looking at that data, because it wasn't in the system where decisions get made.
WHAT TO DO
Put tenant behavior in the asset review, next to the rent roll. Bookings, badge-ins, event RSVPs, spend. If your quarterly asset meeting has an opex slide and no engagement slide, you're reading half the book.
Fix your labels. If a third of your bookings are "Other," you don't have a data problem. You have a homework problem. Nobody's AI is going to save a dataset that's a third unlabeled.
Then program for what's actually being booked. September is telling you meetings and events. Move dollars and staff toward the rooms people are fighting over, not the sleep pods that were cool in 2022.
The finance team doesn't need the thermostat. It needs the tenant. Wire that in first.