Skip to content

Blog

$100 Million Buys a Tower. It Doesn't Buy a Wednesday.

· Greg Gomer

New York City votes Tuesday on whether to hand Tishman Speyer a $100 million property tax break for a 48-story office tower at 99 Hudson Boulevard. Bloomberg reported it Thursday, Propmodo picked it up Friday. The numbers: $2.7 billion, 1.3 million square feet, shovels in the ground in January, doors open in 2030.

The fight is already shaping up the way these fights always do. Watchdog groups say Hudson Yards doesn't need the help anymore, and they've got a point. Some of the highest office rents in the city. BlackRock, Wells Fargo, KKR down the street. The Partnership for New York City says approve it or watch the capital go somewhere else. The IDA's own math says the break costs the city $92.2 million and generates $860 million in tax revenue.

Both sides are arguing about square footage. Nobody's arguing about the thing that decides whether a tower actually works when it opens in 2030.

WHAT'S HAPPENING

Here's what our buildings did from April through August. Across the entire portfolio, 96% of every event RSVP landed on a Tuesday, Wednesday or Thursday. Monday and Friday combined pulled about 4%.

And it isn't just that operators schedule fewer events on the shoulder days, though they do. Monday and Friday were about 8% of the event calendar. The problem is what happens when they try. The average Thursday event drew roughly three and a half times the RSVPs of the average Friday event. About double a Monday. Tenants aren't only skipping Friday. They're skipping Friday programming even when somebody bothered to plan it.

There's a second signal sitting right next to that one. Over the same five months the number of events across the portfolio fell about 16%. RSVPs per event rose about 32%. Fewer events, bigger rooms. Operators consolidated the calendar and tenants rewarded them for it. Nobody sent a memo. The behavior just moved.

WHY IT MATTERS

Leesman has been telling us this for a while. Midweek is the peak, Mondays and Fridays are far quieter, and nearly a third of employees say they have no fixed routine at all. Half of employees name bonding and socializing as the main reason they come into the office in the first place. Informal social interaction is the office's second biggest edge over home, 32 points in the average building and 40 in Leesman+ certified ones.

Put those together. The one thing people commute for is other people. And our data says the social product only works when the room is full. A Friday panel with fourteen RSVPs isn't an amenity. It's a reminder that the building is empty, delivered with catering.

Now go back to Hudson Yards. That $860 million in projected tax revenue assumes bodies in the building, on the days that matter, for years. The Spiral across the street works because it's full of Pfizer and HSBC and AllianceBernstein, and because the whole district gets programmed like a place instead of a parking garage for desks. That's operating. It's not a subsidy. And nobody is holding a public hearing on it.

WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT

Stop spreading programming across five days to look busy. Concentrate it. Your tenants already voted with their calendars. Put the budget on Tuesday through Thursday and make those three days undeniable.

If you want a Friday, earn it. Do something that only works on a Friday, or don't do anything. A half-empty Friday event costs you more in perception than it saves you in a calendar that looks full.

Measure RSVPs per event, not events per month. Event count is a vanity metric for property managers. RSVPs per event tells you whether people want to be in a room together, which is the entire premise of the office.

And if you're underwriting anything that opens in 2030, remember the pro forma assumes a Wednesday. Every one of them. You can budget for the building and forget the calendar, and a lot of people are about to.

New York can decide Tuesday whether to pay for the tower. The tower still has to earn the Wednesday.