Skip to content

Blog

Big Tenants Are Running Out of Options. That's Not the Same as Choosing You.

· Greg Gomer

Savills just told the largest office tenants in America something they already suspected: there's nowhere to go. Across 16 North American markets, only 12.2% of buildings can offer a contiguous 50,000 square feet. Strip out distressed owners and it's 11.5%. Class A only, 7%. Class A in the three best submarkets, 3.3%. Trophy? 0.6%.

Propmodo ran the numbers this week under the headline "Big Office Tenants Are Running Out of Places to Go," and the construction pipeline backs it up. Cushman & Wakefield has the Americas pipeline at just under 32 million square feet, 82% below its 2020 peak. Atlanta has zero office projects under construction for the first time in 15 years.

Then SL Green reported Q3 on Wednesday. Manhattan same-store occupancy at 95%, up from 92.9% at the end of last year. Replacement leases signed 13.6% above prior escalated rents. Average lease term on the quarter's deals: 10.7 years.

Read those two stories together and you get the mood in a lot of ownership groups right now. Supply's gone. Tenants are renewing in place (renewals made up more than half of the biggest deals in downtown Chicago and 60% of the top deals in LA). Rents are up. Exhale.

Hear me out: this is the most dangerous moment to own an office building in five years.

WHAT'S HAPPENING

A renewal signed because there was nowhere else to go is not loyalty. It's a hostage situation with a 10-year term. And the tenant knows it.

The tell is already in Propmodo's piece. REBNY tracked 200 Class B buildings across Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens. Average visitation sits at 72% of pre-pandemic. The average is useless. One in five of those buildings is busier than it was in 2019. Nearly a third are at half or less. Same submarkets, same vintage, same "nowhere to go" market. The sort is happening inside the existing stock, building by building, based on who runs it.

Our data says the same thing from the inside. Across HqO's U.S. portfolio, May through September, bookings of quiet rooms and focus space rose about 60%. Private office bookings more than doubled. Meeting and conference room bookings climbed nearly 50%. Lounge bookings fell 13%.

Here's the one that surprised me. Event registrations across the portfolio dropped roughly 44% from June to September. Part of that is fewer events (down about 20%), but RSVPs per event fell close to 30%. Meanwhile visitor registrations in September jumped 44% over August to their highest level since early summer, and food and beverage order value rose 7%.

So tenants are showing up more, bringing more guests, buying more lunch, booking more rooms to work in, and skipping the rooftop happy hour. They're not coming for the party. They're coming to work.

WHY IT MATTERS

If you own one of the 0.6%, congrats, you're fine, go enjoy it. For everyone else, the Savills spillover thesis cuts both ways. Yes, demand is walking down the quality ladder toward well-located Class A and upgraded Class B with stable owners. But "upgraded" is doing a lot of work in that sentence. REBNY's dividing lines were experienced ownership, transit, and a diversified tenant roster. Not a pickleball court.

Leesman's data has said this for years and the market keeps relearning it. The average office scores 69.5 on the Leesman Index. The average home scores 79.5. The things that close that gap are boring: noise, quiet rooms, temperature, a chair that works. Even Leesman+ certified workplaces only hit 77% satisfaction with chairs. The office doesn't lose to home on amenities. It loses on the basics.

And the scarcity window has an expiry date. Savills is already asking when top-of-market rents justify building again. SL Green's 10.7-year terms sound like security, but a tenant who renewed under duress in 2026 starts planning its 2036 move in 2031, and it'll have options by then.

WHAT TO DO

Stop reading your renewal rate as a retention score. Find out who renewed because they wanted to and who renewed because the broker came back empty. The second group is your churn risk, just delayed.

Then look at what your buildings are actually showing you. If quiet rooms are booked solid and the lounge is empty, that's a capital plan. If RSVPs per event are falling, the answer is fewer, better events on the days people are already there, not more pizza. If visitor volume is spiking, your lobby and access flow are now part of the product.

The buildings on the right side of REBNY's split aren't winning because tenants had no choice. They're winning because tenants would've chosen them anyway.

Scarcity is a market condition. It's not a strategy.