Office NOI Grew 1% in Five Years. Insurance Grew 35%. You Can't Cut Your Way Out of This.
· Greg Gomer
Bisnow ran a story last week that should be taped to the wall of every asset management office in the country. Trepp went through five years of CMBS-backed office financials, 2021 through 2025, and found that median operating expenses grew 2.7% a year while revenue grew 1.3%. Net operating income grew 0.2% a year. Over the full five years, opex was up 14.3%, revenue was up 6.7%, and NOI was up 1%.
One percent. In five years. And NOI was negative in both 2024 and 2025.
This is happening while vacancy is falling in most major cities. Occupancy is recovering and margins are still shrinking. Sit with that for a second.
WHAT'S HAPPENING
The cost side is brutal and mostly out of your hands. Property insurance was the fastest-growing line, up a median 6.1% a year and 34.6% over five years. On the West Coast it ran 9.2% a year. Utilities were second, up 4.9% a year and 27.1% over the period. Repairs, payroll, admin, and management fees all grew faster than revenue too. And none of that includes the capex owners have been pouring into lobbies, fitness centers, and food halls to compete for tenants.
So the reflex is to attack costs. Renegotiate the cleaning contract. Squeeze the property manager. Turn the lights off earlier.
Here's the problem with that. You can't negotiate your insurance premium down 35%. You can't argue with the utility. The two biggest cost drivers are structural. The only line on that P&L a landlord actually controls is revenue, and revenue is a function of one thing: whether tenants stay, expand, and pay for what you built.
Our platform data shows how unevenly that's going.
We looked at every building in our U.S. portfolio with meaningful booking volume and compared June through September against the three months before it. Summer is a down period for everyone, so the direction isn't the story. The spread is. Roughly one in six established buildings grew resource bookings through the summer. About 40% lost 30% or more. A Chicago riverfront landmark was up 56%. A Denver CBD tower was up 47%. A suburban Atlanta property was up 36%. Meanwhile buildings in the same cities, on the same platform, with comparable amenity spend, were down by a third or worse.
Same market conditions. Same insurance environment. Same utility bills. Opposite results.
WHY IT MATTERS
Trepp's data says the average office building is running a business where costs compound and revenue doesn't. Our data says "average" is hiding two very different buildings.
Building A spent the capex, opened the amenity floor, and treats it like a sunk cost. Nobody's tracking whether the rooms get used. Nobody's programming the space. Nobody knows which tenant's usage dropped off in July. That building is paying full opex on the amenity and getting zero pricing power from it. It's an expense line pretending to be a differentiator.
Building B spent the same money and runs it like a product. They know that roughly 40% of bookings across our portfolio happen same-day, so the building has to work in real time, not on a monthly calendar. They know midday access activity is climbing, up from about 21% to 25% of daily door unlocks in our data, while the 8am rush is shrinking, so they staff and program for a flatter day. They know which tenants are engaging and which ones went quiet.
Building B is the one in six. Building A is the 40%.
Our own Experience Gap research puts numbers on the difference: experience-poor buildings run 8% lower occupancy, 17% lower rents, and a 23% NOI drag. When Trepp says NOI grew 1% in five years, that's the blended number. Some owners are well above it. A lot are well below it.
WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT
Stop treating amenities as capex and start treating them as revenue lines with a utilization target. If a space isn't hitting the target, you don't have an amenity. You have a cost.
Measure engagement at the tenant level, not the building level. The 40% decline in bookings didn't happen to the building. It happened tenant by tenant, and the renewal conversations 18 months from now are being decided right now by who's still showing up.
Run the building for a flat day. If a quarter of access activity is midday and 40% of bookings are same-day, your operating model can't be built around a 9am arrival and a Tuesday newsletter.
And accept that the cost side is what it is. Insurance and utilities are going to keep climbing. The only way NOI moves is if tenants pay more and stay longer, and tenants only do that in buildings that earned it.
Trepp is telling you the average office is a shrinking-margin business. Your job is to not be average.