Oppenheimer Just Paid $66 Million to Take 50,000 Fewer Square Feet
· Greg Gomer
Oppenheimer & Co. signed for 220,000 square feet at RXR's 32 Old Slip this week. It's leaving 270,000 square feet at 85 Broad Street to do it. Fifty thousand fewer feet. And RXR and the firm are putting roughly $66 million into the space to make the move work.
Do the math. That's about $300 a foot of fit-out, on a smaller footprint, in the submarket with one of the highest vacancy rates in Manhattan. Nobody downsizes like that. That's a repricing of what a square foot is for.
WHAT'S HAPPENING
Bisnow's Ciara Long had the details on Monday. Six floors, Gensler on the design, move-in starting in the first quarter of 2028, a $3.2 million state grant, and more than 1,000 jobs staying in the Financial District. Oppenheimer's CEO Robert Lowenthal described the move as an investment in culture, "bringing our teams together on six floors with modern technology and a dedicated space to welcome clients."
Read that quote twice. Teams together. Clients welcomed. Not one word about headcount or desks.
The backdrop makes it stranger. Cushman & Wakefield put western FiDi vacancy at 26.7% at the end of the third quarter. And yet tenants signed 4 million square feet south of Canal in the first half of the year, with asking rents up 8% in July over the prior year. Newmark's third quarter report, also out this week, says the same thing at national scale: leasing up 18% year over year, vacancy down to 19.8%, six straight quarters of positive absorption. Class A rents up 2.7%. Class B flat.
So leasing is up, and the deals are smaller and richer. Both things are true.
Here's what the buildings are showing us. Since mid-September, small conference room bookings across our US portfolio are up somewhere between 15 and 20%. Large conference room bookings over the same stretch are flat. Fewer feet, more rooms, smaller rooms. The game room, of all things, booked at more than double its fall average in the most recent full week. Weekday daytime door unlocks are up about a quarter since the week after Labor Day. People are in the building and they're using it in smaller groups, more often.
And it isn't evenly spread. Of the 20 busiest buildings in our portfolio in October, 14 grew bookings over September and six shrank. One property doubled in a month. Another lost about a quarter. Same economy, same month, same platform.
Then there's Leesman. Across more than a million workplace responses, the single biggest edge the office has over home is hosting visitors. A 43-point gap in the average office. A 56-point gap in a Leesman+ building. Informal social interaction is next, at 32 and 40. Lowenthal put "a dedicated space to welcome clients" in his press release. He read the data without ever reading the data.
WHY IT MATTERS
Tenants aren't buying less office. They're buying less space and more building. Per-foot spend is going up while footprint goes down, and the fit-out number is the tell. The average tenant improvement allowance in major markets runs around $87 a foot. This deal is more than three times that. When a tenant pays triple to occupy less, the square foot stopped being the product. The experience inside it is the product.
That also means the headline leasing number is lying to you a little. An 18% jump in leasing volume feels like 2019 is back. It isn't. The same tenant that used to take 270,000 feet now takes 220,000 and spends more on it. If your building can't support the three things the office does better than home (hosting, social connection, learning from each other), you're in the 26.7%, and no amount of lobby renovation gets you out.
The portfolio divergence is the same story one level down. The building that doubled and the building that lost a quarter are competing for the same tenant. One of them is going to get the next Oppenheimer. The other is going to get a broker's email about a sublease.
WHAT TO DO
Stop measuring demand in feet. Measure it in use. Booking frequency, room mix, visitor volume, time of day. A 20% rise in small-room bookings is a leasing signal, not a facilities stat.
Underwrite the fit-out as an operating decision, not a capex line. RXR is co-investing in Oppenheimer's space. That's a landlord acting like a partner, and it's going to be the norm on every trophy deal from here.
Program the client-facing stuff first. Reception, hosting, event space, the places visitors see. That's where Leesman says the office wins, and it's where the tenant's CEO is already looking.
Know which of your buildings is the one that doubled and which one lost a quarter. Then find out why. The answer is almost never the building. It's the operator.
Oppenheimer didn't shrink. It concentrated. Fifty thousand fewer feet, three hundred dollars a foot, and a building that has to earn every one of them. That's the deal now.