San Francisco Just Proved the Building Isn't the Product
· Greg Gomer
San Francisco leased 12.1 million square feet of office through the third quarter. That's up 49% from last year and on pace for one of the best years the city has had in decades. And the guy on stage at Bisnow's State of the Market, John Meany from Presidio Bay, looked at the 28% vacancy number and said it's misleading. Not because it's too high. Because a big chunk of that stock "candidly will not lease."
Read that again. The hottest office market in America has a third of its buildings that nobody wants at any price.
WHAT'S HAPPENING
The AI tenants are chasing 100K-plus square foot blocks and they're paying up for the right ones. Class A vacancy in San Francisco was around 12% last quarter. Class B was north of 31%. The rent premium for the good stuff is 54%. Same city, same zip codes, same fog. Two completely different markets.
Then Greg Kuhlman from Related Ross said the thing I've been saying for three years, except he said it on a panel so now it counts. "The No. 1 tool of an office building is not the amenities within the building. It's everything outside the four walls of the building, whether that's gyms, coffee shops or places to gather with colleagues."
Leesman has the number on that. Across the Lmi benchmark, leisure facilities onsite or nearby score 35% satisfaction. That's the worst-scoring item in the survey, and it's been the worst-scoring item for years. The average office sits at 69.5 on the Leesman Index. The average home sits at 79.5. Ten points. The commute has to earn that gap back, and right now only 62% of employees even say they're satisfied with the commute itself.
So the market is telling you what the data already told you. Tenants aren't buying square footage. They're buying a place their people will actually go.
WHY IT MATTERS
Here's what our own platform shows about how that plays out inside the buildings that win. Gyms are the single most-booked amenity by volume across our portfolio, and they're used by a small, habitual group who book over and over. Conference rooms reach the most unique people by a wide margin. Collaboration space is more than 70% of all resource activity. Phone booths are booked out in every building that has them.
And the top and bottom of the portfolio are moving in opposite directions. A downtown Minneapolis tower nearly doubled weekly engagement in six weeks. A Park Avenue tower slid 35% over the same stretch. Same platform, same tools, different operators. The aggregate hides everything.
That's the Presidio Bay point from the other side. A 28% vacancy rate doesn't describe any actual building. Some buildings in that number are at 5%. Some are at 60% and will never recover. The averages are useless because the market has split, and the split isn't class or vintage. It's whether anyone running the building has a reason for people to show up.
WHAT TO DO
Presidio Bay put more than $100M into a 1967 tower at Spear and Mission to turn it into what they're calling an "office resort." Hear me out, I'm not saying everyone needs a resort. I'm saying they understood the assignment. Good bones, good views, good location, then the money goes into the experience layer, not another lobby renovation.
If you own Class B right now, you've got two options. Reposition toward the thing tenants are paying a 54% premium for, or accept that your building is in the "will not lease" bucket and price accordingly. There's no third door.
If you own Class A, don't get comfortable. The premium is for the experience, not the address. The moment your gym is empty and your conference rooms are booked by the same twelve people, you're drifting toward the other side of the split. Measure it. Leesman tells you where you stand against the benchmark. Your booking and access data tells you whether the building is alive or just occupied on paper.
And stop treating the neighborhood like it's someone else's problem. Kuhlman is right. The coffee shop across the street is part of your product. The gym two blocks over is part of your product. The best operators program around that, partner with it, and sell it on the tour.
San Francisco isn't a comeback story. It's a sorting story. The buildings with a reason to exist are leasing at record pace. The ones without are being written off in public, on stage, by the people buying them.
The building was never the product. The experience was. San Francisco just said it out loud.