Terraces In, Gyms Out, Guests Gone
· Greg Gomer
Employee door activity across our portfolio has multiplied several times over since April. Guest traffic over the exact same five months is down more than a third.
More people badging in. Fewer people getting let in. Same buildings, same months.
Commercial Observer published a piece yesterday on Manhattan Class B office getting dragged into the amenity game. Larry Getlen reported it, and the leasing numbers behind it come from CoStar. Class A new leasing in New York dropped in the first half of this year, from 11.6 million square feet to 10.3 million. Class B and C new leasing hit around 7 million, which beats each of the past three years and beats the 2015 to 2019 average of roughly 6.4 million. B and C are back to about 40% of new leasing after sinking to 31%. CoStar's read: the recovery isn't a trophy story anymore.
Michael Cohen at Williams Equities has the best line in it. "I sometimes laugh when I look at what was once considered a setback and a good place to put air-conditioning equipment. Today, that's a terrace." Grant Greenspan at Kaufman: "We don't call them 'basements' anymore. They're 'lower levels.'" Love that.
WHAT'S HAPPENING
Terraces in, gyms out. That's the shift the reporting found, and I believe it. Cohen's reasoning is exactly right. You can't outsource a bike room to the neighborhood Crunch, but you can absolutely outsource a gym.
Here's what nobody in the story measured. Since April, roughly a fifth more of our properties logged guest activity, and total guest volume still fell by more than a third. Per building, guest traffic is down close to half. Over those same five months the employees walked back in at a rate we haven't seen before in the data.
So the buildings got fuller and more closed off at the same time.
It's more concentrated than that. Roughly nine out of ten guest check-ins across the entire portfolio land in three properties. Everybody else is running a building that basically never hosts anyone from outside the tenant roster.
Guests are also more locked to the middle of the week than employees are. Tuesday is the peak. Tuesday through Thursday takes about 72% of weekday guest traffic. Friday gets under 11%. Employee traffic is broader than that now, and we watched it flatten at the edges last month. The people who already signed the lease are showing up on more days. The people who haven't signed are showing up on fewer.
WHY IT MATTERS
Leesman has measured this for years across more than a million workplace responses, and the finding is blunt. The single thing an office does better than somebody's kitchen table is host visitors. A 43 point gap in the average office. Fifty-six points in Leesman+ certified buildings. Informal social interaction runs 32 points and 40 points. Focus work, private calls, confidential reading, thinking? Home wins every one of those, by wide margins.
Now read that with the guest data sitting next to it. The office's one unbeatable function is hosting. Guest traffic is falling.
That's the flight to quality argument collapsing into something much simpler. A tenant doesn't pay a premium for a building where they sit quietly. They pay for a building where they can bring a client, run a board meeting, host 45 people at a launch and skip the hotel ballroom.
The Commercial Observer piece has a tenant saying that out loud. Pariveda moved 27 people into a Class B building at One NoMad, and the thing they praised wasn't the terrace or the gym. It was hosting a 45 person grand opening in the building's own space, with a screening room for client demos, instead of paying an outside venue. That isn't an amenity. That's cost defense with a guest list attached.
WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT
Pull your guest log. Not your badge count. Your guest log. Look at guests per thousand square feet, by building, over the last five months. If that line is falling while your occupancy climbs, your building is turning into an expensive break room.
Then stop underwriting amenities on attendance. Every owner in that article is spending capital on terraces and lower levels and measuring the return in how many people show up. Attendance was never the point. Jeff Buslik at Adams & Company said the quiet part out loud: the owners installing Class A amenities are the ones who have no choice, and the real differentiator is service and value, not bells and whistles. He's running about 2% vacancy across 7.5 million square feet. He's allowed to say that.
And design the front door for the person who doesn't work there. Registration that takes thirty seconds. A lobby team that knows the name before it's said. Elevator credentials that just work. All three of our top guest properties do this well. Not a coincidence.
Terraces in, gyms out. Fine. But the amenity that shows up in a renewal is the one your tenant's clients walk into.